Bathtub or Shower: Which Is the Best Choice for You?

Bader Obeid • August 26, 2016

Some bathrooms may look more elegant with a nice tub, while others may only have the space to permit a small shower. Even if space is not a concern, some people still prefer the convenience of a shower or the ability to relax in a bathtub. In case you’re planning on remodeling your bathroom and adding a tub or shower, the flooring and design experts at CMA Flooring in Carrollton, TX, have created this handy chart that covers a few of the advantages and disadvantages of both options.

SHOWERS

Space

If bathroom space is at a premium, showers leave a smaller footprint. Though showers can be as large as space allows, the typical configuration is at least 30 inches wide and between 34 and 36 inches deep.

Efficiency

A quick shower beats out a bath because it uses fewer gallons of water per minute. The average 5-minute shower will use up 12.5 gallons.

Access

Showers, especially walk-ins, provide easy access, which is convenient for the disabled and seniors who have limited mobility and difficulty getting in and out of tubs. A shower can also have roll-in or curbless features, offering more opportunities for independence than a bath.

Features

If you prefer a shower, foregoing a bathtub may allow you to install a larger standalone walk-in shower with special features like massaging showerheads.

Resale

According to the National Association of Realtors, potential homebuyers prefer at least one bathtub, but aren’t necessarily willing to give up having a shower, especially families with children. Though having only a shower or bathtub doesn’t reduce a property’s value, it may be slightly harder to sell or rent.

BATHTUBS

Space

The average bathtub is somewhere in the vicinity of 30 inches wide. However, a tub is usually about 72 inches long, taking up a lot more room than a normal shower.

Efficiency

If your showers tend to go long, a tub might be the better choice. A 10-minute shower uses 25 or more gallons, less than filling a bathtub.

Access

Manufacturers are developing access tools for both the disabled and seniors, including benches and taller walk-in tubs.

Features

Tubs offer the advantages of Jacuzzi features, opportunities to read quietly with a glass of wine, and many other things that make relaxing in water a wonderful experience.

Resale

According to the National Association of Realtors, potential homebuyers prefer at least one bathtub, but aren’t necessarily willing to give up having a shower, especially families with children. Though having only a shower or bathtub doesn’t reduce a property’s value, it may be slightly harder to sell or rent.

Once you’ve decided if you’re installing a tub or shower, your next consideration should be choosing new flooring for your bathroom. At CMA Flooring, we offer a wide variety of tile, vinyl, and laminate flooring Carrollton homeowners love. Stop by our showroom or give us a call at 972-418-6606 and one of our friendly and knowledgeable representatives would be happy to assist you.

Why Choose Us?

Our experts work closely with customers to achieve the looks that fit their lifestyle without sacrificing quality or value. We offer:
View All Products
Complimentary in-home estimates
In-house sample & display making
Large stock of materials
Competitive pricing for major brands
Flexible work hours with trained staff
Highly skilled and trained installation teams

More Topics & Ideas

By Baha CMA September 4, 2025
As a design consultant, I spend a lot of time guiding clients through the finishing touches that make their remodels feel both beautiful and lasting. More often than not, I recommend a look that’s soft, timeless, and effortlessly elegant. That look now has a name: the cashmere kitchen — and it’s still going strong. So, what is a cashmere kitchen ? Think of it like your favorite cashmere sweater: soft, classic, comfortable, and a little bit luxurious — without being flashy. Some designers even call it a soft neutral kitchen or a timeless kitchen. The idea is the same: subtle luxury that feels as good as it looks. Key Elements of a Cashmere Kitchen Cabinets : Warm neutrals such as soft greige (J&K Pebble) paired with a warm wood accent like J&K Butterscotch. Countertops : White quartz with gentle gold and brown veining for a polished yet understated look. Hardware : Champagne bronze for subtle warmth; matte black for contrast on darker cabinets. Floors : Light, natural hardwood like Regal Alton to keep the space airy. Backsplash : Glossy, handmade-look tile (SOHO Surfaces) that adds texture and visual interest. Overall feel : Everything flows together. No harsh contrasts — just understated details that shine. This is what makes the cashmere kitchen such a perfect example of a comfort luxe kitchen : elegant, but inviting. Why Homeowners Love a Cashmere Kitchen A cashmere kitchen design checks a lot of boxes for today’s homeowners: Timeless appeal – Won’t feel dated in a few years. Easy to personalize – Add your own touch with lighting, décor, or barstools. Resale - friendly – Neutral palettes appeal to a wide audience. Relaxing atmosphere – The mood is calm, cozy, and inviting. It’s the perfect balance of modern and classic — Shaker cabinet doors provide tradition, quartz countertops keep it current, and metallic hardware adds polish. Many homeowners see it as a classic warm neutral kitchen because it feels both stylish and practical. Cashmere Kitchen vs. Transitional Kitchen
CMA Waterproof Laminate
By Bader Obeid August 21, 2025
Discover why Dallas homeowners are upgrading to waterproof laminate flooring. Stylish, durable, and affordable — CMA helps you design and install the perfect floors.
floor
By Bader Obeid March 24, 2017
Changing out the flooring in your home can be pricey. However, certain materials might be a little easier on your budget without sacrificing quality.
home design trends
By Bader Obeid March 10, 2017
Spring is just around the corner, which means you may want to change up the design of your home to match the season. These ideas will get you started.
dog on fence
By Bader Obeid February 24, 2017
If you leave your dog in the front or back yard, you'll definitely need some type of fencing. These 5 materials offer the protection you're looking for.
plumbing
By Bader Obeid February 17, 2017
When making plumbing renovations in your home, you may need to inform your insurance. Here are a few reasons to tell them about the changes you make.
rustic
By Bader Obeid February 10, 2017
If you're going for a rustic look in your home, there are certain flooring types you should consider. The 4 options on this list may be just what you need.
deck
By Bader Obeid February 3, 2017
Adding a deck to your backyard gives you a good excuse to relax outdoors more often. If doing this project yourself, take a look at the following tips.
wood
By Bader Obeid January 27, 2017
If you're considering new wood flooring for your home, reclaimed wood is an attractive alternative. This type of flooring offers many great advantages.
garden
By Bader Obeid January 20, 2017
One of the most important features of a home is the yard, and turning this area into an entertainment space can make it even more useful and enjoyable.